You Boys in Green Homepage YBIG Shop
Forum Home Forum Home : International : Republic Of Ireland
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - Player Ratings
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login


Player Ratings

 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <1 45678 9>
Author
Message
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 22 Feb 2022 at 10:54pm
22/2/22

Championship

Sean McLoughlin 4 

Seemed to lack confidence all evening, along with Greaves, just didn’t look at all settled.

Jordan Shipley (82, for Maatsen) 6

Worked hard when he went on.

Dara O'Shea 4

It was good seeing O’Shea getting minutes from the off again after so long, and perhaps it’ll take more minutes for him to be back to his best, though right-back wouldn’t be his favoured role. He did struggle here. Good in the air and in the tackle, but awareness and positioning was lacking as Boro cut Albion open.

Jayson Molumby 6

This was better from Molumby before he’d even bagged his first goal for the club. In truth, running and energy has never been something he’s lacked, though there he does that quality in tight areas when the midfield battle intensifies.

Aaron Connolly 6

Similar to Balogun. The ball went long once too often first half which didn't help him. No shortage of effort, but not much of a chance to shine in this one as it never really dropped for him.

Alan Browne 7

Full of pressing and aggression in the middle of the pitch and made those dangerous channel runs. Saw a low shot first half saved.

League 1

Mipo Odubeko 6.5

A lively presence off the bench. Helped give Rovers more impetus in the final third.

Gavin Bazunu 6

Gavin Bazunu was hardly tested, but had a rare poor lapse of judgement led to Leahy getting a free header, coming too far off his line as Leahy nodded in. Very little to do at all after that, good in his distribution and keen to move the ball fast when needed. 

Sean Raggett 6

A brilliant clearance early on from Sean Raggett was key to deny Matthew Pennington, but he, Bazunu and Ryan Tunnicliffe could all be blamed for not dealing with Leahy from the corner. Solid barring that, moving into a back four for the second half as the Blues looked to exploit Shrewsbury's numerical disadvantage. Not his worst game, but not one of his best either.

Ronan Curtis 7 (Star man)

Ronan Curtis was Pompey's best player of the night, his crossing was largely impressive and almost all of Pompey's good moments came with Curtis involved. His first half cross led to O'Brien's equaliser, as well as creating a couple of golden chances for George Hirst, who should have done better in front of goal. Started a No.10 but he ended the night on the left wing. Involved in a post-match scuffle with Leahy, but during the game he was impressive and was the reason Vela was sent off. 

Aiden O'Brien 7

O'Brien marked his first start in a Pompey shirt with his second goal for the Blues in as many games, a poacher's finish to steer former Sunderland teammate Hume's initial effort in. Quiet before his goal, he got more involved in the game after notching, showing up Tyler Walker with two goals already in very little game time. Played a deeper role after the break and was a surprise player to be taken off for Walker in the second half.

Marcus Harness 5

Pompey's top scorer was introduced off the bench at the halfway point in a bid to throw an extra attacking player into the fold, with his introduction leading to a change in shape to a 4-2-3-1. After struggling to impact the game when coming on, he ended as a right-back in a very attacking formation.

Kieran Sadlier 7

Went to the left wing-back slot but didn't have a great deal of impact from that position, as such, but was in the right place to fire home key second goal.
Back to Top
Sponsored Links


Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 24 Feb 2022 at 12:21am
22/2/22

League 1

Anthony Scully 6.5 

Worked hard but not his best game. Will need to show more as City fight for survival. 

Luke McNally 7.5 (Star Man)

Caused problems several times by bringing the ball out from the back. Defensively sound, winning important headers and big tackles. Showcased his speed and strength by racing back to disposess Christopher Long early on.

Mark Sykes 6.5

Involved in some good stuff before the break and one excellent driven cross deserved a finish. Agyei kept him honest, particularly towards the end, but he did enough to limit his former teammate's threat.

23/2/22

Championship

Eiran Cashin 7

Composed on the ball and in his defending, hit one absolute belter of a pass out to Ebosele. Another hugely-promising performance by the young defender.

Jason Knight 6

Worked his socks of as normal, kept plugging away.

Festy Ebosele 6

Two or three strong surges in the first half without an end product. Seemed to pick up an injury late in the half. Replaced for the second half.

Sammie Szmodics 6

Played on the left which probably isn't ideal. Enjoyed a couple of promising attacking moments. Almost forced the goalkeeper into a first-half error with his pressing. Substituted late on.

Mark McGuinness 5

Almost turned home an early header to give Cardiff the lead, then followed it up with a horror tackle to pick up a yellow.

Joel Bagan 6

A quieter night for the left back - but he was due one! Up against Sorba Thomas and did well enough. Tired a bit later on.

Jimmy Dunne 7

Scored with a lovely header and his all-round performance was committed and effective but, not for the first time in recent weeks, his failure to clear his lines led to a goal.

Jeff Hendrick 7

Showed his experience and battling qualities on a tough night for Rangers.

John Egan 7

Tough first half, booked after Gallagher looked to skip away from him but came into his own in the second half with United under real pressure.

Darragh Lenihan 6

Like the rest of the defence, the captain was solid on his return to the side and made some important challenges to deny some goal bound efforts. Was rarely troubled by Sharp and his passing allowed Rovers to counter quickly. Should have commanded the area better to deny the late goal.
Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 26 Feb 2022 at 8:28pm
25/2/22

Premier League

Shane Long (for Adams, 82) 5

Didn't do too much when he came on as the lone striker.

26/2/22

Premier League

Matt Doherty 8

Scored his first Spurs goal and followed it up with an assist five minutes later in his best performance for the club. Should have had another but took a heavy touch and Illan Meslier rushed out to save.

Seamus Coleman 6

Set the tone with a combative challenge on De Bruyne by the touchline in the first half that had the home fans on their feet. Despite coming up against the fleet-footed Raheem Sterling, he still managed to get forward on occasions.

Championship

Darragh Lenihan 6

Lead by example and provided that stability needed in the back five this afternoon. Won a lot of tackles to ease the pressure on the Rovers defence and his passing allowed them to break on the counter multiple times.

Jimmy Dunne 8

Another fine display from the Irishman, who was the pick of the Rangers’ central defenders. Marshalled the physical threat of Gallagher well and showed good pace to deal with Blackburn’s small but mobile forwards.

Jeff Hendrick 6

Some tidy passing, including one peach of a ball to find Adomah in the box. Had a chance late in the game but was unable to get his head to Sam McCallum’s cross.

Aaron Connolly (for Siliki, 46') 6

Unlucky to have a goal disallowed but helped spark a better Boro second half.

Mark Travers 8

Was unable to keep out Tommy Smith's driven strike at the far post, but made a key flying save to stop Stoke from doubling their lead when it was 11v11. His distribution wasn't quite as precise as usual in the opening stages, with Stoke's incremental press causing problems.

But made a monstrous save at the death to once again tip the promotion balance in Bournemouth's favour.

Mark McGuinness 6

A decent enough showing from the centre back. Had a couple of hairy moments but generally did well defending his box.

James Collins 5

Missed an absolute sitter in the first half, hitting a one-on-one straight at Marek Rodak. Ran his socks off, though.

Joel Bagan (for Doughty 67) 6 

A nice outing for the left back. Almost netted the equaliser with a header late on.

Alan Browne 7

Solid performance from the captain, getting back in to cover and defend when required while showing the confidence to drive forward with the ball. Set up a first-half chance for Evans and passed pretty well.

Eiran Cashin 7

Solid, calm and strong defensively. Another impressive performance by the young defender.

Jason Knight 6

Created an early chance for Kazim-Richards.

Festy Ebosele (for Bird, 66) 6

John Egan 5 

Had a good chance to give United the lead in the first half with a free header that was straight at the keeper.

Conor Hourihane 4 

Not as influential as in recent weeks. Delivery and passing was not as good as it has been.

Sammie Szmodics 5.5

He was busy as always, but the position behind the front two needs a good passer of the ball, one with vision. Missed a great chance to score a consolation goal.

Sean McLoughlin 7

Calm, composed and found himself in little trouble in the first period, a theme which continued into the second.

League 1

Mipo Odubeko 6

Ran the channels and gave Griffiths some much-needed support as a half time replacement for Williams.

Anthony Scully 5.5

Struggled to make an impact in the first half. A little more involved in the second after swapping sides with Maguire, but isn’t the threat he looked earlier in the season. 

Kieran Sadlier 5.5

Went to left wing-back slot like against Lincoln, saw shot from the edge of the box blocked.

Gavin Bazunu 5

Gavin Bazunu has not let in three goals in many games all season, never mind in the opening 45 minutes of a match at home to a bottom half side. Good Pilkington and Biggins finishes perhaps could not be blamed on the Republic of Ireland international, but when Lane beat him from some way out on his side, he will have been frustrated not to have batted it away. 

Sean Raggett 7

Sean Raggett could not remotely be blamed for Pompey being 3-0 down before the break, with all of Fleetwood's goals and the move for them coming down that side. He fought and found himself in a very competitive tussle with former Blues colleague Ellis Harrison. Caused problems when got forward and swept up at the back, summed up when he got straight back up again after finding himself shoved over the hoardings.

Marcus Harness 7

Pompey's top scorer Marcus Harness was back in the starting line-up for the first time in a fortnight, lining up as a right winger, back to the position he is best known for, even if he has not played there all that often this season. Good link up play with those around him and his creativity and reformed partnership with Tunnicliffe proved to be the source of much of Pompey's promise. Part of the bundle in the box for Curtis' croner which was given to him. At his best, his quality makes him too good to ignore, and there were flashes of it, especially in the second half. 

Ronan Curtis 8 (Star man)

Curtis was the man at fault for Pilkington's opener as former Blues colleague Ellis Harrison sprinted and shurgged past him before crossing for Pilkington to convert. Tried to cause problems with his crossing but failed to really do so, although he did have the big say on the first half when converting the penalty won on the stroke of the interval, converting well from his first ever penalty in blue. That goal gave him a lift and was at the heard of everything good for much of the second half, creating multiple good chances and seeing a header off the back post clip the top of the bar. His early error quickly avenged by his excellence in the second half when his corner created Harness' bundled second. Picked up a very harsh booking in the second half that suspends him for the next two games.

Aiden O'Brien 7

Aiden O'Brien would be allowed to feel hard done by for not earning back-to-back starts after a goal on his full debut at Shrewsbury. Seconds after coming on, he did well to steer a header on goal from Tunnicliffe's cross. Became the late hero when going through clean on goal and slotting past Alex Cairns, his third goal in as many games. 

Scottish Premiership

Joe Shaughnessy 6
Charles Dunne 5
Alan Power 6
Connor Ronan 1

Back to Top
Stimpy View Drop Down
Liam Brady
Liam Brady


Joined: 01 May 2014
Location: Dublin
Status: Offline
Points: 1109
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Stimpy Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 26 Feb 2022 at 9:50pm
Originally posted by You Tell Me You Tell Me wrote:

25/2/22

Premier League

Shane Long (for Adams, 82) 5

Didn't do too much when he came on as the lone striker.

26/2/22

Premier League

Matt Doherty 8

Scored his first Spurs goal and followed it up with an assist five minutes later in his best performance for the club. Should have had another but took a heavy touch and Illan Meslier rushed out to save.

Seamus Coleman 6

Set the tone with a combative challenge on De Bruyne by the touchline in the first half that had the home fans on their feet. Despite coming up against the fleet-footed Raheem Sterling, he still managed to get forward on occasions.

Championship

Darragh Lenihan 6

Lead by example and provided that stability needed in the back five this afternoon. Won a lot of tackles to ease the pressure on the Rovers defence and his passing allowed them to break on the counter multiple times.

Jimmy Dunne 8

Another fine display from the Irishman, who was the pick of the Rangers’ central defenders. Marshalled the physical threat of Gallagher well and showed good pace to deal with Blackburn’s small but mobile forwards.

Jeff Hendrick 6

Some tidy passing, including one peach of a ball to find Adomah in the box. Had a chance late in the game but was unable to get his head to Sam McCallum’s cross.

Aaron Connolly (for Siliki, 46') 6

Unlucky to have a goal disallowed but helped spark a better Boro second half.

Mark Travers 8

Was unable to keep out Tommy Smith's driven strike at the far post, but made a key flying save to stop Stoke from doubling their lead when it was 11v11. His distribution wasn't quite as precise as usual in the opening stages, with Stoke's incremental press causing problems.

But made a monstrous save at the death to once again tip the promotion balance in Bournemouth's favour.

Mark McGuinness 6

A decent enough showing from the centre back. Had a couple of hairy moments but generally did well defending his box.

James Collins 5

Missed an absolute sitter in the first half, hitting a one-on-one straight at Marek Rodak. Ran his socks off, though.

Joel Bagan (for Doughty 67) 6 

A nice outing for the left back. Almost netted the equaliser with a header late on.

Alan Browne 7

Solid performance from the captain, getting back in to cover and defend when required while showing the confidence to drive forward with the ball. Set up a first-half chance for Evans and passed pretty well.

Eiran Cashin 7

Solid, calm and strong defensively. Another impressive performance by the young defender.

Jason Knight 6

Created an early chance for Kazim-Richards.

Festy Ebosele (for Bird, 66) 6

John Egan 5 

Had a good chance to give United the lead in the first half with a free header that was straight at the keeper.

Conor Hourihane 4 

Not as influential as in recent weeks. Delivery and passing was not as good as it has been.

Sammie Szmodics 5.5

He was busy as always, but the position behind the front two needs a good passer of the ball, one with vision. Missed a great chance to score a consolation goal.

Sean McLoughlin 7

Calm, composed and found himself in little trouble in the first period, a theme which continued into the second.

League 1

Mipo Odubeko 6

Ran the channels and gave Griffiths some much-needed support as a half time replacement for Williams.

Anthony Scully 5.5

Struggled to make an impact in the first half. A little more involved in the second after swapping sides with Maguire, but isn’t the threat he looked earlier in the season. 

Kieran Sadlier 5.5

Went to left wing-back slot like against Lincoln, saw shot from the edge of the box blocked.

Gavin Bazunu 5

Gavin Bazunu has not let in three goals in many games all season, never mind in the opening 45 minutes of a match at home to a bottom half side. Good Pilkington and Biggins finishes perhaps could not be blamed on the Republic of Ireland international, but when Lane beat him from some way out on his side, he will have been frustrated not to have batted it away. 

Sean Raggett 7

Sean Raggett could not remotely be blamed for Pompey being 3-0 down before the break, with all of Fleetwood's goals and the move for them coming down that side. He fought and found himself in a very competitive tussle with former Blues colleague Ellis Harrison. Caused problems when got forward and swept up at the back, summed up when he got straight back up again after finding himself shoved over the hoardings.

Marcus Harness 7

Pompey's top scorer Marcus Harness was back in the starting line-up for the first time in a fortnight, lining up as a right winger, back to the position he is best known for, even if he has not played there all that often this season. Good link up play with those around him and his creativity and reformed partnership with Tunnicliffe proved to be the source of much of Pompey's promise. Part of the bundle in the box for Curtis' croner which was given to him. At his best, his quality makes him too good to ignore, and there were flashes of it, especially in the second half. 

Ronan Curtis 8 (Star man)

Curtis was the man at fault for Pilkington's opener as former Blues colleague Ellis Harrison sprinted and shurgged past him before crossing for Pilkington to convert. Tried to cause problems with his crossing but failed to really do so, although he did have the big say on the first half when converting the penalty won on the stroke of the interval, converting well from his first ever penalty in blue. That goal gave him a lift and was at the heard of everything good for much of the second half, creating multiple good chances and seeing a header off the back post clip the top of the bar. His early error quickly avenged by his excellence in the second half when his corner created Harness' bundled second. Picked up a very harsh booking in the second half that suspends him for the next two games.

Aiden O'Brien 7

Aiden O'Brien would be allowed to feel hard done by for not earning back-to-back starts after a goal on his full debut at Shrewsbury. Seconds after coming on, he did well to steer a header on goal from Tunnicliffe's cross. Became the late hero when going through clean on goal and slotting past Alex Cairns, his third goal in as many games. 

Scottish Premiership

Joe Shaughnessy 6
Charles Dunne 5
Alan Power 6
Connor Ronan 1


Wonder what Ronan did to deserve a 1 rating.... 
 


Back to Top
Hotlips_Hoolahan View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton
Avatar

Joined: 04 Aug 2020
Status: Offline
Points: 6615
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Hotlips_Hoolahan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 26 Feb 2022 at 9:51pm
Originally posted by Stimpy Stimpy wrote:

Originally posted by You Tell Me You Tell Me wrote:

25/2/22

Premier League

Shane Long (for Adams, 82) 5

Didn't do too much when he came on as the lone striker.

26/2/22

Premier League

Matt Doherty 8

Scored his first Spurs goal and followed it up with an assist five minutes later in his best performance for the club. Should have had another but took a heavy touch and Illan Meslier rushed out to save.

Seamus Coleman 6

Set the tone with a combative challenge on De Bruyne by the touchline in the first half that had the home fans on their feet. Despite coming up against the fleet-footed Raheem Sterling, he still managed to get forward on occasions.

Championship

Darragh Lenihan 6

Lead by example and provided that stability needed in the back five this afternoon. Won a lot of tackles to ease the pressure on the Rovers defence and his passing allowed them to break on the counter multiple times.

Jimmy Dunne 8

Another fine display from the Irishman, who was the pick of the Rangers’ central defenders. Marshalled the physical threat of Gallagher well and showed good pace to deal with Blackburn’s small but mobile forwards.

Jeff Hendrick 6

Some tidy passing, including one peach of a ball to find Adomah in the box. Had a chance late in the game but was unable to get his head to Sam McCallum’s cross.

Aaron Connolly (for Siliki, 46') 6

Unlucky to have a goal disallowed but helped spark a better Boro second half.

Mark Travers 8

Was unable to keep out Tommy Smith's driven strike at the far post, but made a key flying save to stop Stoke from doubling their lead when it was 11v11. His distribution wasn't quite as precise as usual in the opening stages, with Stoke's incremental press causing problems.

But made a monstrous save at the death to once again tip the promotion balance in Bournemouth's favour.

Mark McGuinness 6

A decent enough showing from the centre back. Had a couple of hairy moments but generally did well defending his box.

James Collins 5

Missed an absolute sitter in the first half, hitting a one-on-one straight at Marek Rodak. Ran his socks off, though.

Joel Bagan (for Doughty 67) 6 

A nice outing for the left back. Almost netted the equaliser with a header late on.

Alan Browne 7

Solid performance from the captain, getting back in to cover and defend when required while showing the confidence to drive forward with the ball. Set up a first-half chance for Evans and passed pretty well.

Eiran Cashin 7

Solid, calm and strong defensively. Another impressive performance by the young defender.

Jason Knight 6

Created an early chance for Kazim-Richards.

Festy Ebosele (for Bird, 66) 6

John Egan 5 

Had a good chance to give United the lead in the first half with a free header that was straight at the keeper.

Conor Hourihane 4 

Not as influential as in recent weeks. Delivery and passing was not as good as it has been.

Sammie Szmodics 5.5

He was busy as always, but the position behind the front two needs a good passer of the ball, one with vision. Missed a great chance to score a consolation goal.

Sean McLoughlin 7

Calm, composed and found himself in little trouble in the first period, a theme which continued into the second.

League 1

Mipo Odubeko 6

Ran the channels and gave Griffiths some much-needed support as a half time replacement for Williams.

Anthony Scully 5.5

Struggled to make an impact in the first half. A little more involved in the second after swapping sides with Maguire, but isn’t the threat he looked earlier in the season. 

Kieran Sadlier 5.5

Went to left wing-back slot like against Lincoln, saw shot from the edge of the box blocked.

Gavin Bazunu 5

Gavin Bazunu has not let in three goals in many games all season, never mind in the opening 45 minutes of a match at home to a bottom half side. Good Pilkington and Biggins finishes perhaps could not be blamed on the Republic of Ireland international, but when Lane beat him from some way out on his side, he will have been frustrated not to have batted it away. 

Sean Raggett 7

Sean Raggett could not remotely be blamed for Pompey being 3-0 down before the break, with all of Fleetwood's goals and the move for them coming down that side. He fought and found himself in a very competitive tussle with former Blues colleague Ellis Harrison. Caused problems when got forward and swept up at the back, summed up when he got straight back up again after finding himself shoved over the hoardings.

Marcus Harness 7

Pompey's top scorer Marcus Harness was back in the starting line-up for the first time in a fortnight, lining up as a right winger, back to the position he is best known for, even if he has not played there all that often this season. Good link up play with those around him and his creativity and reformed partnership with Tunnicliffe proved to be the source of much of Pompey's promise. Part of the bundle in the box for Curtis' croner which was given to him. At his best, his quality makes him too good to ignore, and there were flashes of it, especially in the second half. 

Ronan Curtis 8 (Star man)

Curtis was the man at fault for Pilkington's opener as former Blues colleague Ellis Harrison sprinted and shurgged past him before crossing for Pilkington to convert. Tried to cause problems with his crossing but failed to really do so, although he did have the big say on the first half when converting the penalty won on the stroke of the interval, converting well from his first ever penalty in blue. That goal gave him a lift and was at the heard of everything good for much of the second half, creating multiple good chances and seeing a header off the back post clip the top of the bar. His early error quickly avenged by his excellence in the second half when his corner created Harness' bundled second. Picked up a very harsh booking in the second half that suspends him for the next two games.

Aiden O'Brien 7

Aiden O'Brien would be allowed to feel hard done by for not earning back-to-back starts after a goal on his full debut at Shrewsbury. Seconds after coming on, he did well to steer a header on goal from Tunnicliffe's cross. Became the late hero when going through clean on goal and slotting past Alex Cairns, his third goal in as many games. 

Scottish Premiership

Joe Shaughnessy 6
Charles Dunne 5
Alan Power 6
Connor Ronan 1


Wonder what Ronan did to deserve a 1 rating.... 
 



Red card.
Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 27 Feb 2022 at 9:07pm
26/2/22

League 1

Warren O'Hora 7.5

Solid, strong and reliable as ever.

Conor Coventry 7

Made some uncharacteristic mistakes in the first half but recovered with an excellent and disciplined second.

Troy Parrott 8.5 (Star Man)

Took hit after hit, but kept getting up and asking for more. Great on the ball, unselfish, made great runs, dropped deep and added a body defensively too. A sensational all-round game.

Mark Sykes 8

Involved in three goals and his assist for Baldock was a peach. Cambridge found him and Williams very difficult to contain down the right.

Luke McNally 7.5

Dragged out of position for the first goal, although United should have cleared the danger after that. Solid on the ground and in the air, with one shoulder charge on Smith getting a good reception.

27/2/22

Carabao Cup Final

Caoimhin Kelleher 8 (Star Man)

Superb save early on to deny Pulisic and stopped Lukaku at near post at end of normal time. Confident with his handling and distribution.

Scottish Premiership

Jake Doyle-Hayes 6

Struggled to get on the ball, such was Celtic’s dominance of possession. But put in a huge shift in the middle of the park.

Jake Carroll 6

Ross Tierney 5

Incidentally Sky Sports gave Kepa a 0 for his League Cup final display. Can't remember seeing a 0 rating before.

Back to Top
Eoink21 View Drop Down
Liam Brady
Liam Brady


Joined: 30 Aug 2019
Status: Offline
Points: 1207
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Eoink21 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 27 Feb 2022 at 9:23pm
O'Hora is an interesting one. Still very young and seems to get a 7 at least every single week in this ratings compilation. McNally seems to be getting good game time at Oxford. It will be interesting to see who goes up and who can make the step up. 
Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 01 Mar 2022 at 11:01pm
 
28/2/22

Championship

Ryan Manning 8

The Irishman made a number of important tackles on the left side of Swansea's back three and mopped up well to recover when his side put themselves under pressure. Should have had an assist for Michael Obafemi, but a fine effort nonetheless.

Cyrus Christie 8 (Star Man)

Operating on both flanks during various stages, Christie linked up well with others in attack and was well denied by Sam Johnstone with a header in the first half. Composed to net his second Swansea goal which put the icing on the cake.

Michael Obafemi 7

Worked tirelessly and played his part in several attacks. Spurned a golden chance to score with a header before being substituted.

Dara O'Shea 3

A forgettable half for O’Shea, in general. Yes, he’s just back from injury and is not playing in his favoured position, so there is a little mitigation, but his positioning and distribution - bar one excellent cross for Robinson’s header onto the post - left a lot to be desired.

Jayson Molumby 3

The delivery of his set pieces was pretty woeful throughout. Plugged away but his deliveries and simple passes from open play were lacking the sufficient quality all too often.

Callum Robinson 5

The only player who, on the face of it, looked likely to score tonight. Hit the post twice, though he should’ve converted at least one of those chances.

1/3/22

Premier League

Nathan Collins 6

Called upon for injured Mee and did okay.

Championship

Mark McGuinness 5

Cards on the table, he wasn't at his best. Gave the ball away far too often and was a little sloppy defensively.

Joel Bagan 6

Festy Ebosele had the better of him with his incredible pace. Put in a couple of nice crosses in attack, though.

Eiran Cashin 8

Impressive again. Sold defensively, won his headers and showed a calmness on the ball.

Festy Ebosele 7

His pace troubled Cardiff throughout the first half. He needed to show more composure with his end product, but he was a constant threat from the right.

Jason Knight 6

Never stopped grafting for the team.

League 1

Gavin Bazunu 6

Gavin Bazunu's wait for a clean sheet extended by another game after seeing Browne beat him on the angle within minutes of the start of the game. Had little to do for the rest of the first half but did make one good save to deny Sam Long's volley at the end of a corner in the second half. 

Sean Raggett 8

Like Carter, Raggett could be held accountable for not dealing with Oxford's forward line when Browne put the visitors ahead early on. But again, like Carter, he also got his name on the scoresheet. Defended well, barring Oxford's early chance and goal and put the game level with his third goal in the space of five appearances, heading brilliantly on the end of Joe Morrell's floated cross. Helped to manage the game brilliantly late on as one of the Blues' most in form players this season

Marcus Harness 7

Marcus Harness went into the game off the back of celebrating reching ten league goals for the season for the first time in his career at the weekend. It was a slow start to the game for Pompey's top scorer this season, playing on the right of the two behind Hirst. Better when he switched sides with Aiden O'Brien, showing real quality with the directness of his run, the timing and execution of his through pass that lead to Hirst putting Pompey ahead. A quieter showing after the break and was taken off so that Pompey could shore up more, but his class shone in the move for Raggett's goal.

Aiden O'Brien 6

Aiden O'Brien is one of Pompey's top scorers in the league this season with three goals in his last three outings, with such form rewarding him with a second start since his deadline day switch. A quiet first half showing, barring some good link play. Ended the game as a left winger and from the side, created a golden chance for Hirst, with his header being saved by a top stop from Jack Stevens. Great work also at the end to carry Pompey up the pitch and keep the ball, but his goal run did end.

FA Cup

Sammie Szmodics 8

Put in a terrific shift for the team. Worked so hard defensively even though he must have suffered from twisted blood trying to keep tabs on the skills of Mahrez and Joao Cancelo. He did miss a great chance to open the scoring though. 

Jack Bonham 6

Elected for flying punch to deal with corner that led to Palace second. 

Tayo Adaramola 7

Always looking to push forward and help out Wilfried Zaha on the wing. Also looked to hit Jean-Philippe Mateta where possible with a long ball before being pinned back a little in the second half.

Matt Doherty 5

Threatened to follow up his first goal for the club with another, but blazed over with the goal gaping before sending a low effort wide. Faded as the game went on and offered next to nothing in the second half.

Back to Top
Stimpy View Drop Down
Liam Brady
Liam Brady


Joined: 01 May 2014
Location: Dublin
Status: Offline
Points: 1109
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Stimpy Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 02 Mar 2022 at 8:18am
Robinson loves the aul 5 ratings
Back to Top
aviva8 View Drop Down
Liam Brady
Liam Brady


Joined: 08 Nov 2011
Status: Offline
Points: 1322
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote aviva8 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 02 Mar 2022 at 8:55am
How someone who watched that match could give obafemi a 7 and Robinson, molumby 5 and 3 respectively is baffling.
Back to Top
Eoink21 View Drop Down
Liam Brady
Liam Brady


Joined: 30 Aug 2019
Status: Offline
Points: 1207
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Eoink21 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 02 Mar 2022 at 9:45am
Originally posted by aviva8 aviva8 wrote:

How someone who watched that match could give obafemi a 7 and Robinson, molumby 5 and 3 respectively is baffling.

The answer is that it's probably not the same person. While these ratings are brilliantly pulled together and always worth a read, it's always important to consider the biases involved. We have seen, for example someone with an agenda against Doherty constantly rinse him or simply just give him a mark or two what is probably reasonable (albeit that's coming from an Irish supporter trying to manage their own biases!). 
Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 02 Mar 2022 at 11:33am
Yes, those West Brom v Swansea ratings are all over the place, especially on the West Brom side. I watched the game and I'd have scored each of the Swansea Irish players a point lower than what they were given, but the West Brom ratings in particular are poorly done and I think reflect the writer's frustration at how their season has panned out more than anything. It wasn't just the Irish lads, pretty much the whole team was given 3s and 4s. Robinson was actually one of the highest scorers with 5. They weren't great, but they weren't that bad.

Just to clarify also they're from different sources - the Swansea ones are from Wales Online and the West Brom ones are from Birmingham Live. Each site only covers their own team so ratings for two opposing teams are rarely written by the same person, unless it's a local derby.




Edited by You Tell Me - 02 Mar 2022 at 11:33am
Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 05 Mar 2022 at 7:31pm
1/3/22

League 1

Luke McNally 7.5 (Star Man)

Defensively strong and a threat going forward. Dominant in the air, while he brought the ball out of defence well and is starting to master the overlapping centre back role. Great finish to give United hope.

2/3/22

FA Cup

Will Smallbone 7

In his first appearance for the first team since December, he tried a few early flicks that didn't come off. Generally neat and tidy in midfield thereafter and put in a couple of testing deliveries from the right in a good shift as he got 80 minutes.

Shane Long 6

Playing up top alongside Adam Armstrong, he got up in the air well to win headers and flick-ons against Kurt Zouma and Issa Diop.

Took a couple of heavy falls and a knock before being replaced at half time.

Peter Kioso 7.5

Came in at right wingback and with Town understandably not seeing too much of the ball, his opportunities to get forward were fairly limited. Still got stuck in against his more illustrious opponents all evening though with some important clearances.

3/3/22

FA Cup

Seamus Coleman (59 for Mykolenko) 6

Solid outing for the last half an hour.

4/3/22

Championship

John Egan 4

Had a shocker of a first half. Sloppy and gave the ball away on several occasions. United were all over the place at the back in the first 45 and Forest were unlucky not to go in at half-time in front. In the right place to get a crucial tackle in on Davis in the second half.

Sammie Szmodics 5.5

A mixed bag. Set up a couple of first-half half chances, but also lost the ball a bit. One snapshot just cleared the bar from 25 yards.

5/3/22

Premier League

Nathan Collins 5

Headed first half chance over and was pretty good in first half but part of defensive collapse in second.

Shane Duffy 6

On the whole did well against Chris Wood in a good old rough and tumble, of sorts. This match was a return to form for the Irishman after a rough display against Burnley in his last match.

Championship

Darragh Lenihan 6

Needed to organise his defence better during the first period as Rovers were often left open at the back on a number of occasions during the first half. His personal performance was solid, and often came out the better against Fulham's attack.

Eiran Cashin 7

The young defender continues to turn in strong, composed performances. This was another.

Festy Ebosele 7

Started the game at left back but was still able to surge forward and ask questions of Barnsley. Moved to an attacking role on the right when Ebiowei went off.

Taylor Gardner-Hickman 8

The player who many Albion supporters had been calling to see - and in midfield, too. Bruce decided to change things in the middle and TGH was able to show him what he was capable of. He’s still quite raw and does make the odd wrong decision, or pass, but generally he brought energy, positivity and benefitted from playing with the more experienced heads.

Callum Robinson 6

Did okay here. Could’ve been more dynamic in possession and some of his crossing didn’t beat the first man, but he occasionally interchanged effectively with Grant and continued to be the first line of defence in the second half as Albion sat.

Sean McLoughlin 5

Steady away but couldn’t prevent Grant from notching up a brace at the MKM Stadium. 

Aaron Connolly 6

Difficult afternoon for Connolly as it just wouldn't drop for him much. Improved in the second half with his hold up play and flicks but it was a stop-start affair that didn't help his cause. You can't fault his effort though.

Alan Browne 6

Was having a hit-and-miss afternoon but not for a lack of fight or effort. And when the game reached the crunch stage, he was there to make a crucial block to deny Ryan Christie at one end and then set up Emil Riis at the other. A captain's shift.

Mark Travers 6

Made a key stop to deny Cameron Archer in the first half but could do very little about the forward's goal in the second. The shot was from close range, and the speed shot meant Travers could only proffer the obligatory attempt of a dive (same applied for their second goal) Did everything else he had to do.

Mark McGuinness 8

Back to somewhere near his best. Flew in front of a number of crosses and shots. Looked far better.

Joel Bagan (Doughty '56) 7 

Made a big impact on the left when he came on and played in Davies for the leveller.

Jack Bonham 5

Saved well from Madine in first half and collected crosses. 

Ryan Manning 6

Faced a stern test against Todd Kane for much of the afternoon. Stood up reasonably well, but like his colleagues found himself stretched as the game progressed.

Cyrus Christie 6

A pretty quiet outing compared to recent showings. Plenty of endeavour, but couldn't quite influence things as much as he might have liked.

Michael Obafemi 8 (Star Man)

Two goals and one assist. First brace of his career. His pace terrified the Coventry defence. One of his best showings in a Swans shirt.

League 1

Mipo Odubeko 4

Got his chance to start but failed to take it. Offered no goal threat and remained on the fringe of the game.

Kieran Sadlier 6

Slotted into number 10 role and looked bright on the ball after coming on.

Gavin Bazunu 8

A couple of quiet performances and showings for Gavin Bazunu before facing Accrington, he showed some great saves and was back at his best. Accrington may have lost 4-0, but they dominated in terms of regularity and volume of shots. Really commanding despite facing an Accrington team all about physical domination and set-pieces. Important timing with three away games on the spin. 

Sean Raggett 8

Pompey's in-form goal machine is not one of the forwards, but instead centre-back Raggett, who doubled the Blues' lead within ten minutes of Harness' red card. A thumping header off Ryan Tunnicliffe's lofed corner just before the hour mark doubled the Blues' advantage. A master at doing the basics so well and his form throughout this season has been nothing short of top-notch. Developing into a real leader in the way he fights and defends throughout. 

Marcus Harness 3

It turned from hero to zero very quickly for Harness, whose first half sending off left Pompey with ten men for 70 minutes and leaves them another man down for the next three games. Having been a key part of the move that led to Hirst opening the scoring, linking up well with Romeo before the latter assisted, Harness was sent off minutes later for a two-footed lunge on Ross Sykes. Having not won a foul for an Accrington challenge, he reacted badly with almost a scissor kick-esque lunge and he can have no complaints at getting sent off. He will now miss trips to Crewe Alexandra, Ipswich Town and Plymouth Argyle in the next three games. 

Aiden O’Brien 8

It was a quiet first half for Aiden O'Brien but in the second half, it was his skill that created two goals. For Hirst's second, he carried the ball some way and with a cleverness to win the corner. He then went one better minutes later, dribbling from deep in his own half, skipping past two players and teeing up Tunnicliffe to finish. A fans favourite already, the ball sticks to him like glue and his ability of close control and causing nightmares is just one of many reasons why he has been such a smart signing. 

Scottish Premiership

Jake Doyle-Hayes 6
Dan Cleary 5
John Mahon 4
Jonny Hayes 6

Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 06 Mar 2022 at 4:03pm
5/3/22

Championship

Jimmy Dunne 6

Well below his best and was caught out on a couple of occasions when he lost concentration from long balls forward which presented Cardiff with some decent opportunities.

Jeff Hendrick 5

Disappointing performance from the on-loan midfielder, who gave the ball away poorly on quite a few occasions and did not provide much creativity from midfield alongside a more defensive-minded player in Field.

League 1

Luke McNally 9.5 (Star Man)

Pretty much the perfect all-round performance. Burton allowed him to bring the ball out and he took advantage, adding another dimension to United's attack. Won everything the air and made some fantastic challenges.

Mark Sykes 9

Showed impressive energy to get up and down that right flank all game, causing Burton all sorts of problems. Classy assist for Baldock and went close to scoring a few times.
Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 09 Mar 2022 at 2:23pm
7/3/22

Premier League

Matt Doherty 9

No question his best game for Spurs. Finished with two excellent assists for Kane and nearly scored when he fired a fierce effort at Pickford. Linked up well with Kulusevski in a really encouraging display.

Seamus Coleman 3

As proud and as passionate as they come for Everton, he’s a modern day great but you wonder whether the time to hand over the baton to Nathan Patterson is approaching as he struggled to get near Tottenham’s marauding attackers at times.

8/3/22

Championship

Jack Bonham 6

Some steady hands in first half and little to do in second except pick ball out of net.

Darragh Lenihan 6

Performed well against the experience of Benik Afobe. Was often the only defender in the back three to press forward and try and aid the Rovers attack. Was composed on the ball and was dominant in his aerial duels.

Mark Travers 6

Didn't have a lot to do. Couldn't have done anything about the goal.

Jack Taylor 7

Good to have the midfielder back on the pitch and he cruised through his 65 minutes comfortably. Could be a big player in the weeks to come.

Sammie Szmodics (for Taylor, 66) 7

Bright, busy and effective. Encouraging.

John Egan 7 

Stood up well in the first half when Connolly was running at him and would have got in behind had he not read the tackle. Then picked out Robinson for the third with a back-post header that was slotted home by his defensive team-mate.

Conor Hourihane (for Fleck, 38) 6

Aaron Connolly 5

Can't fault his graft up top as he battled away all game but it was another evening little came off for him.

Ryan Manning 4

The Irishman started well but a wild challenge ultimately cost his side the game. It's a red that will no doubt be debated, but in the modern era, it was a huge risk and he got nowhere near the ball when lunging in on Harry Wilson.

Michael Obafemi 6

Starved of the ball in the first-half but played his part in a collective effort. Fired wide in the opening half and then withdrawn as part of a damage limitation exercise.

League 1

Gavin Bazunu 5

Against Accrington Stanley, Gavin Bazunu had to work hard for his clean sheet, but despite little pressure from a Crewe side, who in the 90 minutes only came close when hitting the bar twice, the same could not be said. Gave away a chance at back-to-back clean sheets when spilling through his own legs at a Long shot in stoppage time.

Sean Raggett 8

The best of the back line was Sean Raggett, who came close to taking his goal record to five in seven games when forcing a save in the first half, only for Walker to tuck away the rebound. Brilliant at the back and solid throughout, once again leading by example at the head of the defensive trio.

Ronan Curtis 7

Having missed the last two games following a suspension for ten yellow cards, Ronan Curtis was back in the squad and replaced suspended teammate Marcus Harness in the starting side. Involved in the passing move for the opening goal on the counter and came close to scoring himself twice in the first half from range, one from open player and one from a free-kick where Walker should have slotted. Suiting the number ten position, blending his physical prowess with his creativity. 

Aiden O'Brien 5

Shortly after Hirst's second, he was taken off for the second time in four days while on a brace for Aiden O'Brien. O'Brien likely to have only dropped to the bench as Cowley tries to manage his small squad as best as possible.

Anthony Scully (for Maguire 69) 6.5

Kieran Sadlier 6.5

Played centrally after coming on and some fresh energy and decent touches at times.

Warren O'Hora 7

A quiet but effective performance from the defender. Never really in any trouble.

Conor Coventry 7.5

Kept Dons in time and in line as he mopped up in front of the defence. Looked like he had eyes in the back of his head at times.

Troy Parrott - 8 (Star Man)

Who else?! A hugely popular brace for the forward after a long drought.
Back to Top
amccarten313 View Drop Down
Davey Langan
Davey Langan


Joined: 29 Mar 2015
Location: USA
Status: Offline
Points: 997
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote amccarten313 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 09 Mar 2022 at 6:38pm
wonder what will happen with jack taylor if peterborough go down, he is out of contract in the summer and just coming back from injury now
Back to Top
Hotlips_Hoolahan View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton
Avatar

Joined: 04 Aug 2020
Status: Offline
Points: 6615
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Hotlips_Hoolahan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 09 Mar 2022 at 6:58pm
Originally posted by amccarten313 amccarten313 wrote:

wonder what will happen with jack taylor if peterborough go down, he is out of contract in the summer and just coming back from injury now

Has he stood out or something?
Back to Top
amccarten313 View Drop Down
Davey Langan
Davey Langan


Joined: 29 Mar 2015
Location: USA
Status: Offline
Points: 997
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote amccarten313 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 10 Mar 2022 at 12:38am
Originally posted by Hotlips_Hoolahan Hotlips_Hoolahan wrote:

Originally posted by amccarten313 amccarten313 wrote:

wonder what will happen with jack taylor if peterborough go down, he is out of contract in the summer and just coming back from injury now

Has he stood out or something?


from what ive seen over the course of the year seems like he was playing every week when healthy, dont think hes had as much success as last year in league one when they got promoted but peterborough have scored 25 and conceded 70 through 35 matches so i doubt anyone would look good in that team
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <1 45678 9>
  Share Topic   

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.00
Copyright ©2001-2018 Web Wiz Ltd.