You Boys in Green Homepage YBIG Shop
Forum Home Forum Home : International : Republic Of Ireland
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - Player Ratings 2022/23
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login


Player Ratings 2022/23

 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <1 34567 8>
Author
Message
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (1) Thanks(1)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 13 Nov 2022 at 6:11pm
8/11/22

League Cup

Mark Travers (Bournemouth) 6

Handed another chance to build some confidence heading into the weekend and delivered. He tipped over a rasping drive from James Garner in the first half but was largely untested before the break. Demarai Gray's strike was too hot for him to handle, despite his acrobatic dive.

Mark Sykes (Bristol City) 5

Made a good run towards the back post where his header was saved by Rushworth. His crossing wasn't up to scratch and Lincoln were able to exploit the space behind him and put the pressure on Low. Came off at half-time with Weimann dropping to wing-back.

Paudie O’Connor (Lincoln) 9 - Star Man

Simple outstanding from Paudie. Not only did he get the all-important third, the Irishman also made a goal-saving block at 3-0 to deny Conway.

Sean Roughan (Lincoln) 7

Struggled more in the second half when Bristol seemed to double up on him. Had a good first half though and got to grips nearer the end.

Luke McNally (Burnley) 6

A threat from attacking set pieces but will be disappointed with Crawley opener.

Dara Costelloe (Burnley) 6

On the fringes of the game but kept at it before being replaced.

Warren O'Hora (MK Dons) 8 - Star Man

Scored a brilliant volley to give Dons the lead. Led the defence in fine fashion again en route to their fourth straight clean sheet.

Conor Grant (MK Dons) 7

Built on a solid performance off the bench on Saturday with a good effort on Tuesday. Set up Dennis to score, and looked a threat in parts.

Darragh Burns (MK Dons) 7

Had a lively opening half-hour, finding space and joy in between the lines before Morecambe switched system to smother his influence.

Dawson Devoy (MK Dons) 6.5

Went through the motions in the centre of the park, letting Dons cruise to victory.

Scottish Premiership

Liam Scales (Aberdeen) 6 

Tough night for the Celtic loanee as the defence had a rough start to the game but eventually grew into the tie.

Championship

Scott Hogan (Birmingham) 7

Ghosted between the Swansea defenders for his ninth of the season. He pressed vigorously but when he did win the ball back he struggled to find the necessary quality on his pass.

Ryan Manning (Swansea) 7 

After a slow start, the Irishman caused havoc on the left flank and played a key role in his side's first goal. Put in some really good deliveries and worked hard defensively too. Should have done better from the corner that led to Troy Deeney's goal though.

CJ Hamilton (Blackpool) 7

Limited impact in a game that had already passed Blackpool by.

Darragh Lenihan (Middlesbrough) 7

Might have scored from a glancing header. Untroubled at the other end of the pitch.

Callum O'Dowda (Cardiff) 5

Cut a frustrated figure at times owing to his lack of involvement. Found himself defending a lot early on.

Callum Robinson (Cardiff) 7 - Star Man

Hull did an excellent job at keeping him quiet early on. He tried to run in behind but struggled for quality service. But he needed just one chance to score after excellent play from Ralls and floated a fantastic ball into Whyte for his goal.

Jimmy Dunne (QPR) 6

Given Rangers’ defensive woes from set-pieces in recent weeks while he has been out injured maybe he should have started the game? Didn’t have much to attack as Huddersfield sat deep hanging on to their lead. Tried to be a nuisance in the box.

John Egan (Sheffield United) 5

Had United's best effort up to that point early in the second half when he allowed McAtee's good pass over the top to drop and then leathered a volley goalwards, but Johansson did well to tip it over.

Enda Stevens (Sheffield United) 5

Was perhaps fortunate not to concede a penalty late in the first half as he tangled with Wiles and the Millers skipper went down. On first glance it looked like a pen and replays didn't do much to challenge that view. Thought he had scored in the first half but he was flagged offside. Made way for Sharp.

Jack Bonham (Stoke) 6

Benefited from some shots coming into his lap, or credit to his positioning. Kicks often went straight to Luton keeper. 

Will Smallbone (Stoke) 7

Largely operated in front of his own area but useful on the counter with some clever passes. 

Jeff Hendrick (Reading) 4.5

Lacked any real impact on the game. Too often took the safe option which took the sting out of the side's attacking play.

9/11/22

League Cup

Matt Doherty (Tottenham) 4

Endured a wretched night with his error leading directly to Forest’s first goal.

Mark McGuinness (Sheffield Weds) 8

Dominant in the air and stuck to his task. Had his pocked pinched once by Walcott after Stockdale played him into trouble. Is so calm and composed under pressure.

Conor Coventry (West Ham) 5

Horrendous backpass put Markanday through on goal before being sacrificed for more attacking Benrahma.

Sam Szmodics (Blackburn) 6

The boyhood Hammers fan got the final 30 minutes after coming on for Dack.

Nathan Collins (Wolves) 7

Collins has been heavily criticised for his defensive work recently, but the 21-year-old had some good moments in this game after a shaky start. He won lots of headers, distributed the ball well and held the Wolves defence together alongside Kilman. Collins played his part in the goal by winning the ball back and setting Podence away down the right.

Joe Hodge (Wolves) 6.5

Hodge slotted in alongside Neves in Wolves’ 4-2-3-1 shape and plugged away in midfield. The Irishman did well on his full debut.

Connor Ronan (Wolves) 6.5

Ronan tried to bring some invention to Wolves’ attack in an attacking midfield role and came closest to a goal while he was on the field. Ronan saw his flick saved by Robles after breaking free of his marker inside Leeds’ penalty area.

Caoimhin Kelleher (Liverpool) 9 - Star Man

Some nice goal kicks first half. Forced into routine saves from Dobbin and McGoldrick in last 10 minutes, and three excellent stops in the shoot-out.

Eiran Cashin (Derby) 8 

Got away with a poor touch that led to a Liverpool chance in the first half but that mistake aside, he had a fine game in the heart of the Derby defence.

Conor Hourihane (Derby) 7 

Pace of the game suited him and he picked out a terrific pass that found Louie Sibley in the first half which the midfielder should have done better with. Experience told on many occasions. 

James Collins (Derby) 7 

In a game like this, you always knew he would be a peripheral figure in which it was all about his work off the ball. He kept plugging away.

David McGoldrick (Derby) 6

Produced a peach of a pass for Dobbin late on as Derby nearly pinched a goal on the counter. 

11/11/22

Scott Hogan (Birmingham) 6.5

He was lively, running off the shoulder and finding space in behind, however I don't think anyone expected him to score when he went clean through just before half time. Kept going to the very last.

12/11/22

Premier League

Mark Travers (Bournemouth) 7

Largely untested in the first half, with his defence dealing well with direct crosses into the penalty area. He denied substitute Tom Cannon's header late in the game, and dealt well with deliveries into the box.

Seamus Coleman (Everton) 6

Came off the bench to play out of position at left-back with his side already 2-0 down, the veteran captain led by example but others were unable to follow.

Tom Cannon (Everton) 7 - Star Man

Premier League debut came hot on the heels of his senior bow here on Tuesday – with a brace against Paris Saint-Germain for the Under-21s in between – and he went close with a header from a Gordon cross soon after going on, providing Everton’s otherwise toothless attack with a different dimension.

Gavin Bazunu (Southampton) 5

Wasn't positioned well for Firmino's opener but made an excellent, close-range save to deny Mohamed Salah shortly after. Came out and claimed several balls into his box but was also beaten inside the six-yard box but Darwin Nunez twice.

Matt Doherty (Tottenham) 6

Put in the dangerous cross that led to Spurs' third goal for Bentancur and gave Leeds something else to worry about down the right.

Nathan Collins (Wolves) 6

Collins’ last two appearances represent an improvement on his Brighton showing. He looked comfortable on the right of Wolves’ back three and his distribution was good.

Championship

Max O'Leary (Bristol City) 7

Was a spectator for the majority of the first half. The trend continued into the second half with Watford failing to register a shot on target.

Callum O'Dowda (Cardiff) 6

Was involved in most of the positive things that happened going forward and struck up a fantastic partnership with Robinson. Hit a number of dangerous crosses and passes into the box. Faded a little when moved to left-back.

Callum Robinson (Cardiff) 6

A little bit of a frustrating one, because 90% of the things he did were brilliant, but that final 10% was missing. Had a number of efforts on goal but couldn't find the back of the net.

John Egan (Sheffield United) 7

Won a lot of headers as Cardiff targeted the wide areas to get crosses in, particularly through O'Dowda but Egan was equal to those. Former Blade Callum Robinson was lively though and one moment in the first half he left him trailing and got in behind. Strong performance after the break as he led the defence with United looking to hold on to their 1-0 lead.

Enda Stevens (Sheffield United) 6 

Much improved performance from the Republic of Ireland defender. A moment of concern early on when he gave the ball away and put his side in danger but defended well on the whole.

Jimmy Dunne (QPR) 6

Did well on his return to the starting line-up but ultimately it was in vain as Gyokeres scored twice.

Ryan Manning (Swansea) 7

Some good deliveries from set-pieces and was always an outlet on the left flank. Tested Nicholls with a shot from wide in an encouraging performance.

Michael Obafemi (Swansea) 7

The forward made some brilliant runs up the pitch and had Huddersfield's defence on edge with his pace. Struck the post with a fine effort.

Armstrong Oko-Flex (Swansea) 6

Was very direct but couldn't have the all-important impact in dangerous areas.

Jeff Hendrick (Reading) 6

Escaped with just a yellow card at the end of the first half when he went in late on Woods despite loud cries for a red. Had a rather up and down performance overall, with some defensive lapses but he did keep things ticking over reliably in the middle.

Shane Long (Reading) 6

Back in the side and handed his first start in over two months. Worked incredibly hard as ever, running the channels and forcing Hull's defenders into quick decisions. Held the ball up well but needed more support from his teammates.

Darragh Lenihan (Middlesbrough) 7

Looked uncomfortable for half an hour with Norwich's attack, but his leadership and composure helped Boro settle and get to grips.

Robbie Brady (Preston) 7

Allowed the cross to come in for Millwall's opener a tad easily, but got to grips with the game after that and caused problems with his crossing. Used the ball pretty well and put in a shift, before being taken off after Millwall's third - the cross for Flemming having come down that side again.

Alan Browne (Preston) 6

Attacked the ball well for the first PNE goal and carried the ball forward with energy at times. Was competing well but lost a key 50-50 in the middle of the park, Millwall scored a few seconds later and he then made way. Performance went downhill after his and Brady's withdrawal.

Sean Maguire (Preston) 5 

Pretty isolated up there with Riis. Played the final 10 minutes or so.

Dara O'Shea (West Brom) 8

A superb, selfless display. Body on the line throughout. Did the simple things really well. Playing with dedication from O'Shea isn't anything new to him, but he just has that added intensity to his game at the minute.

Jayson Molumby (West Brom) 8

It might be a footballing cliché, but he really did cover every blade of grass. Molumby is more than just a runner, though. There were times when he displayed good ability in possession, not least of all his sharp turn to get Thompson booked.

Jack Bonham (Stoke) 5

Beaten by Swift, Harry Clarke and Bartley in first half, with a couple then stopped on line, then Thomas-Asante in second. 

Will Smallbone (Stoke) 4

Too weak in the tackle too often. Should have cut out pass in build-up to opener. Some neat passes but too inconsistent.

League 1

Mark McGuinness (Sheffield Weds) 7

Another impressive showing from the Cardiff City loanee. Was strong in the air and maintained his concentration levels throughout. Looked a cut above most of the players on the pitch.

Jack Taylor (Peterborough) 6

His shooting and attacking play looked improved in this one and he was tidy on the ball but Tim Dieng was his man at the first goal and he just stood there and allowed him to glance the ball home. 

Marcus Harness (Ipswich) 6 

The attacker kept the ball better than he has done in recent weeks and helped his team, while also having chances which would have won the game had he been able to take them. Thundered off the underside of the bar in the first-half and then, after the break, headed wide when presented with a good cross from Chaplin. He should have scored that one. Could perhaps have done more to get back into the picture and try to prevent the visitors’ leveller. 

Paudie O’Connor (Lincoln) 6

Another good performance from the Irishman in defence.

Warren O'Hora (MK Dons) 5.5

Part of that back line which never dealt with Derby's aerial threat.

Conor Hourihane (Derby) 7 

Delivered the corner from which Roberts scored and it was from another of his set-pieces that led to Collins grabbing a second for the Rams. Has had a tough week through illness but showed quality. 

James Collins (Derby) 7 

Played up front on his own and was a peripheral figure in the first half, but he came alive after the break and took his goal with real aplomb. 

David McGoldrick (Derby) 6

Came on to help press MK Dons when in possession.

Sean Raggett (Portsmouth) 6

Plenty more culpable than the defender who stood firm while others wilted.

Mipo Odubeko (Port Vale) 5

Hard to come on and influence a game that was heading against the Vale. 

Scottish Premiership

Liam Scales (Aberdeen) 7

Performed excellently in defence, and had an added spark going forward as he looked to support the attack in creating opportunities.

13/11/22

Championship

Josh Cullen (Burnley) 8 

Recovered possession countless times and produced a really strong performance.

Back to Top
Sponsored Links


Back to Top
Loc View Drop Down
Kevin Kilbane
Kevin Kilbane


Joined: 23 Jan 2021
Status: Offline
Points: 157
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Loc Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 04 Jan 2023 at 10:04pm
Must say I’m missing these…Can only imagine how much work was involved though!
Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 07 Jan 2023 at 12:02pm
Had meant to restart them after the World Cup from the Stephen's Day games when the Premier League came back, but was just too busy over the Christmas to do them. Anyway, things have quietened down again now so I'm going to start them back up, starting with the last week of games.


Edited by You Tell Me - 07 Jan 2023 at 12:04pm
Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 07 Jan 2023 at 12:03pm
30/12/22

Championship 

Sean McLoughlin (Hull) 8

Came close to scoring with a well-worked corner routine. Shanked one late on over his bar for a proper heart-in-mouth moment. 

Cyrus Christie (Hull) 8

Steady enough early on, saw more going forward second and having created plenty, his cross finally got turned in by Oscar.

Adam Idah (Norwich) 8

Epitomised his talent in one dynamic and dangerous performance.His left-wing role allowed him to drive at defenders while also providing the running in-behind that Russell was looking for, and on the ball his quality was evident, most of all when he drove home the opener to give Norwich the lead.

Lovely flick through to Pukki, who should have done better, in the 17th minute. After consistent struggles with injury have frustrated his first few years as a senior player, there's no better time to find form than when a new head coach is set to arrive. 

Jeff Hendrick (Reading) 5

Helped Reading to look reasonably effective today when on the ball, which isn’t something you can always say. Did well to direct the ball around Reading’s side to retain possession, but still looks limited when it comes to breaking the lines. Hendrick’s real problem though is that he still looks like an absolute saloon door off the ball. At many times he may as well not be there. Hendrick won not a single tackle or duel at all tonight and was dispossessed three times. He needs to find some key role in the side in 2023, or there’ll be no repeat loan in 2023/24.

Jack Bonham (Stoke) 5

Came to claim most things but will be disappointed not to do more to stop a slow motion Burnley opener and kicking sometimes wasted. 

Will Smallbone (Stoke) 6

Useful pressing in first half and some decent link up play without being able to really crank it up a gear and be dangerous in the opposition half. 

Josh Cullen (Burnley) 7

Prodded in his first Clarets goal to settle contest and was combative.

Ryan Manning (Stoke) 8

Deliveries from set-pieces were much improved, and the Irishman caused plenty of problems from the left wing. Did plenty of defensive work, making numerous tackles and interceptions in what was a fine display.

League 1

Eiran Cashin (Derby) 9 - Star Man 

Playing so well at this moment in time and this was another game when he won plenty of his duels and made a couple of excellent blocks. Close to a goal too and was outstanding from start to finish.

Conor Hourihane (Derby) 5

Produced a couple of decent deliveries and Derby should be making more of his set-pieces in truth. Would like to see him get further forward at times.

David McGoldrick (Derby) 6

Back in the side after illness and showed one or two mesmerising bits of quality that showed he is a class apart at this level. Had a shot blocked in the second half.

James Collins (Derby) 5

Tended to drift back towards his own goal. and his work-rate is invaluable. Can't fault his effort and is playing the hardest role in the team up front on his own. 

Jason Knight (Derby) 6

Injected pace and drive into the heart of midfield.

Paudie O’Connor (Lincoln) 6

Defended well and helped his team hold onto a point with ten men.

Sean Roughan (Lincoln) 6

Did well against a bright youngster in Conor Bradley. Was solid for most of the game.

Daniel Mandroiu (Lincoln) 7

Was unfortunate to be replaced due to the red card but had looked back to his best. Really intelligent free-kick to supply House.

Kieran Sadlier (Bolton) 5.5

Big chance for him to show he is worth a regular start and though he linked up with Dempsey early on, Wanderers could not get him into the game enough in the second half.

31/12/22

Premier League

Nathan Collins (Wolves) 8

Lively start. Was given an early warning by referee Jones after a rather meaty challenge as he brought the ball out but overran it. Made a crucial challenge to deny Martial after Fernandes' through ball. Fantastic feet to drift through the United midfield before drawing a foul from Fred, but could have done more to prevent Rashford breaking through.

Mark Travers (Bournemouth) 5

Little he could have done for both goals, with the blame lying at the feet of those in front of him. His handling was otherwise unwavering, especially on a slick pitch, and the pressure was eased through a handful of punches and claims.

Gavin Bazunu (Southampton) 6

Made no attempts to hide that he was going long every chance he got to distribute. Was unlucky to concede as he did after Ward-Prowse's deflection. Didn't have too much to deal with in the second half but looked a little shaky when failing to catch a cross from Antonee Robinson that almost allowed Kenny Tete to score. Gave away a late penalty when trying to punch clear but denied Mitrovic from the spot.

Seamus Coleman (Everton) 7

Disciplined cameo as Everton stood firm and made a crucial last-gasp challenge on Phil Foden.

Evan Ferguson (Brighton) 8

Showed good energy and attacking intent when the 18-year-old entered the contest and then bagged his first Premier League goal by shrugging off William Saliba and neatly tucking the ball home. Was a good focal point up top.

1/1/23

Premier League 

Matt Doherty (Tottenham) 6 

Had a lovely link-up with Gil early in the first half before nutmegging Mings in the Villa box only for his shot to be deflected away from goal. Made a crucial sliding tackle to deny Watkins in the Spurs box after the hour mark. 

Championship

Callum O'Dowda (Cardiff) 7 - Star Man

Just about the only player to show class and poise with the ball at his feet. Looked capable of unlocking the left-hand side for City and found space to cross and link-up time and time again.

Callum Robinson (Cardiff) 5

Had to scrap and scrape for every chance. Had one on a plate from Ralls, though, and his low shot was saved. Threw his toys out of the pram when he was subbed.

CJ Hamilton (Blackpool) 6.5

One of four changes made as winger handed start. Notched assist with pass through to Lavery to slot home. Showed good energy but lacked impact in second half and was taken off.

Max O'Leary (Bristol City) 7

Called into action early on by denying Martyn Waghorn with his legs. Unfortunate with the opener after initially making a brilliant save. Safe hands coming out for crosses. Rarely tested in the second half but did everything expected of him.

Louie Watson (Luton) 8

Excellent full league debut for the youngster who took to the holding midfield role like a duck to water. Always eager to show for the ball and receive it from his defenders, while used his body impressively to manoeuvre space away from his markers and get Town on the attack, as his passing was neat, tidy and usually spot on too. Off after just over an hour but it was an impressive one.

League 1

Glenn Whelan (Bristol Rovers) 6

Experience at the back is something the Gas have lacked this season, and Whelan provided that alongside a little game management to help his side over the line.

Ed McGinty (Oxford) 7.5

Not at fault for the Grecians goal after initially making a good save from Jay Stansfield. Made a super stop to deny Josh Key moments later to keep United in the game.

Jack Taylor (Peterborough) 6.5 - Star Man

Played with more energy and drive than most. Unlucky not to score late on when hitting the inside of a post.

Warren O'Hora (MK Dons) 5.5

The defence was slow to start the game, and got pulled apart at times by the Plymouth front line. Caught flat-footed for Plymouth's second.

Dawson Devoy (MK Dons) 6

Was Dons' best midfield outlet, and when they had a spell of pressure, was the key man. But he faded in the second-half.

Sean Raggett (Portsmouth) 5

Not a good day at the office having been at fault for both goals. First being put on the floor by Rak-Sakyi before giving away the ball in the build-up to the second.

Ronan Curtis (Portsmouth) 5

Gave his all like we all know he can but couldn’t get into any attacking areas.

2/1/23

Championship

Darragh Lenihan (Middlesbrough) 8

Brilliant at the back once again. Showed real leadership and played some wonderful balls out of defence, including one early in the second half that put Marcus Forss through on goal.

Ryan Manning (Swansea) 7 - Star Man

Always a threat on the left flank in the first half and defended well too. Indeed, he ended the match with eight tackles in a top defensive effort.

Josh Cullen (Burnley) 7

Burnley didn't control the contest but Cullen recovered possession and was a steady influence.

Dara O'Shea (West Brom) 8

Stood up admirably to the obvious challenge posed by Carroll, his old teammate who he'll have known only too well the qualities he possesses. Won plenty of headers on that front and completed some decent passes out from the back.

Jayson Molumby (West Brom) 9 - Star Man

Magnificent. As strong a hand as Lumley produced to deny him, he really should have put Albion in front when bursting into the box to meet Swift's lay-off. Outstanding battling qualities displayed to win the ball before he then fired in an excellent cross from the right for Dike's goal.

Jeff Hendrick (Reading) 4

The Irishman was bypassed far too often in the midfield as Reading struggled to get a foothold in the game early on. He did find himself in pockets of space on a couple of occasions, but didn't make the most of those moments.

Shane Long (Reading) 5

Brought on against one of his former clubs, he almost got an assist with his flick from an Ince corner, which Rahman headed over.

Sean McLoughlin (Hull) 7

On his 50th start for the Tigers, McLoughlin was involved in the opening goal, brilliant ball for Smith's first.

Cyrus Christie (Hull) 7

One run down the right early on was like prime Cafu. Another fine display, even if the second half was a little more conservative. 

Jack Bonham (Stoke) 6

A very quiet afternoon until excellent save to deny Ben Woodburn late on – but then beaten by Evans’ header.

Will Smallbone (Stoke) 5

Did a lot of the prep work well to win the ball in opposition half in first half but needs to make better use of it. Quiet second half.

Alan Browne (Preston) 7

Grafted away at right wing-back and did a job for the team. Couldn't fault his application or endeavour. Sent in the corner which Evans headed home.

Jimmy Dunne (QPR) 7

The ideal game for Dunne, who was able to show his leadership and battling qualities.

John Egan (Sheffield United) 6

Horrendous error gifted the home side the opener when he tried to pass out from the back but played the ball straight to Chris Willock and then deflected the effort from Ilias Chair into his own net as he tried to block the shot. Then made amends right at the death with the equaliser to earn United a point.

Ciaran Clark (Sheffield United) 6

Used his experience well on a number of occasions to clear the danger. Picked up some good positions and read the play well but came off at half-time with what looked a hamstring injury after he stretched to clear the ball but then felt the back of his leg.

Enda Stevens (Sheffield United) 5 

Came close to scoring in the first half when he lashed an effort just wide. Gave the ball away on a couple of occasions but played a key part in the equaliser by sending the ball into the area for Egan to pounce and that assist will have done his confidence the world of good.

Adam Idah (Norwich) 6

Andrew Omobamidele (Norwich) 5

League 1 

Eiran Cashin (Derby) 8 

Another game, another clean sheet and the 21-year-old is playing so well at the moment. Good in possession too and was a class act once again.

Conor Hourihane (Derby) 8 

A tactical tweak to a 4-3-3 allowed him to get forward more and it proved a shrewd one by Warne as the midfielder grabbed his first goal under the head coach.

Jason Knight (Derby) 9 - Star Man 

Was relentless in the press and won plenty of encouragement from Warne on the sidelines. Powered through midfield and added plenty of zip to the attack from the centre of the pitch.

David McGoldrick (Derby) 8.5 

What's there to say that hasn't already about this maestro? Pulled the strings like a professional puppet master. A brilliant performance capped off with a goal.

Paudie O’Connor (Lincoln) 7

Helped City get an unlikely point with a solid defensive display.

Sean Roughan (Lincoln) 4

Struggled on the left of defence, particularly against Wes Burns.

Daniel Mandroiu (Lincoln) 5

Struggled to impact the game in forward areas before being replaced at half-time.

Marcus Harness (Ipswich) 5

Starting again for the second time in just a few days, the attacker was direct in his approach, having a shot blocked and also having the ball in the net, only to see his effort ruled out after Burns was flagged offside. Replaced in the second half.

Mark McGuinness (Sheffield Weds) 8

We may as well copy and paste this section for McGuinness every game. A rock again.

3/1/23

Premier League

Seamus Coleman (Everton) 6

Provided some experience as Everton tried to hold back the tide.

Evan Ferguson (Brighton) 9

Looked a real threat going forward as his instinctive, first-time hit crashed off the post and he was inches away with a 25-yard piledriver, too. Was in the right place at the right time to fire home for his second goal in two games. The 18-year-old is making it look easy.

Andrew Moran (Brighton) 7

Made his Premier League debut and seemed to love every minute of his cameo.

Mark Travers (Bournemouth) 5

Will be disappointed to have conceded from yet another set-piece, especially one for which he was not at fault. Similarly beaten by Luke Shaw, who profited from a failure to mark him and then haul him down in midfield. United were just too smart for their third goal, which Marcus Rashford tapped home with ease after lapse defending.

4/1/23

Premier League 

Gavin Bazunu (Southampton) 6

Didn't have too much to do in the first half and couldn't do much about the Nottingham Forest goal. Had some nervous moments in the second half but was - again - not tested too much.

Nathan Collins (Wolves) 8

Collins was imperious for most of the match at Villa Park, rebuffing Villa attacks with ease. He has improved greatly under Lopetegui and looks like the player who impressed in the early weeks of the season again.

Joe Hodge (Wolves) 6

Added some fresh legs in midfield and used the ball well alongside Neves and Matheus.

Matt Doherty (Tottenham) 8

Worked hard down the right and got his reward as he stroked home a left-footed shot for Tottenham's third goal.

6/1/23

FA Cup

Seamus Coleman (Everton) 7

United’s first goal came down his flank as Ben Godfrey was left to deal with Rashford but the returning captain epitomised his side’s fighting spirit and despite his advancing years, was full of running.
Back to Top
Bandwagon View Drop Down
Ray Houghton
Ray Houghton
Avatar

Joined: 07 Feb 2021
Location: Dublin
Status: Offline
Points: 3275
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Bandwagon Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 07 Jan 2023 at 2:49pm
Clap
Back to Top
aviva8 View Drop Down
Liam Brady
Liam Brady


Joined: 08 Nov 2011
Status: Offline
Points: 1316
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote aviva8 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 07 Jan 2023 at 2:54pm
Excellent

Edited by aviva8 - 07 Jan 2023 at 2:54pm
Back to Top
darman28 View Drop Down
Liam Brady
Liam Brady
Avatar

Joined: 08 Jan 2012
Location: Sligo
Status: Online
Points: 1176
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote darman28 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 07 Jan 2023 at 3:35pm
Great to see this back, it is great to gauge how our players are playing.

Brilliant work YTM.

Big thanks and appreciation  for all the work, effort and your own time spent writing up these rating.
They are a massive benefit to the forum.
Fair play.
Back to Top
Loc View Drop Down
Kevin Kilbane
Kevin Kilbane


Joined: 23 Jan 2021
Status: Offline
Points: 157
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Loc Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 07 Jan 2023 at 4:00pm
Fantastic! Thanks Clap
Back to Top
djhegzy View Drop Down
Liam Brady
Liam Brady


Joined: 06 Oct 2014
Location: Co. Tyrone
Status: Offline
Points: 1166
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote djhegzy Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 07 Jan 2023 at 4:59pm
Great work really look forward to reading these Smile
Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 07 Jan 2023 at 10:42pm
7/1/23

FA Cup

Gavin Bazunu (Southampton) 7

Kept his place in the team with Willy Caballero on the bench and Alex McCarthy out with injury. Could have done better with the opener, with Odsonne Edouard tucking the ball between his legs and into the goal. Improved afterwards and did well to claim several crosses into his box. 

Alan Browne (Preston) 7

Solid enough shift at right wing-back again. Went close with a shot from the edge of the box, but got his reward late on in the second half when he timed his run well to slot home.

Robbie Brady (Preston) 6

Introduced late on. Good to have him back on the pitch.

Shane Long (Reading) 7

Given a rare start. Suffered an injury midway through the first half which saw his left arm bandaged up. Harried and pressed the Watford defence well, though, and kept up his superb record of scoring in the FA Cup for Reading with a precise finish to cap off proceedings.

Sean Raggett (Portsmouth) 7

Handled Harry Kane & Co superbly, fighting for everything and again reminding us defending is his strength. Never gave an inch.

Andy Lyons (Blackpool) 7.5

Made Blackpool debut at right-back after move from Shamrock Rovers. Looking promising going forwards and won free kicks for his side.

CJ Hamilton (Blackpool) 7

Bursts of pace caused isses for the visitors on the left flank. Good game going forward and added Blackpool's third goal with clinical finish.

Mark Travers (Bournemouth) 5

There was little he could do to stop the opening goal. However, damningly, there were three shots on target in the first half, with all three finding the back of the net. Made a crucial save to deny Anass Zaroury shortly after Bournemouth's second goal, but was beaten by yet another flashing drive from Manuel Benson.

Josh Cullen (Burnley) 6

Awful pass to gift Bournemouth leveller but didn't let it affect him and stuck to his task.

Luke McNally (Burnley) 7

Introduced early and did well albeit his poor pass contributed to Bournemouth second.

Jayson Molumby (West Brom) 5

Brought a little more bite into the midfield but Molumby - who enjoyed a wonderful Christmas period - encountered a determined and battling bunch.

Dara O'Shea (West Brom) 5

Brought about a little more authority at the back for Albion and made one or two crunching challenges on fearless Chesterfield players who continued to come on strong even in the later stages. Summed up Albion's day when passing straight out of play at the end.

Sean McLoughlin (Hull) 7 

Decent performance from the Irishman again in the black and amber. Looks so assured in the majority of what he does.

Aaron Connolly (Hull) 5

Looked very rusty with a couple of heavy touches which is to be expected having only had a couple of training sessions.

Richard Keogh (Ipswich) 7

Started the game confidently, striding forward and getting his side moving into midfield while looking after things at the back. The penalty he conceded was rash as he stretched to deny Washington, who had beaten him into the box, but he recovered from it well enough.

Marcus Harness (Ipswich) 7

The first man off the bench, the attacker had some good creative moments and helped move Ipswich around the pitch.

Evan Ferguson (Brighton) 6

No goal for Ferguson this time out but led the line well and provided a focal for the Brighton attack. In contention to face Liverpool.

John Egan (Sheffield United) 7

Really commanding performance from the Republic of Ireland international. Dealt with everything that came his way but his reading of the game was impressive.

Enda Stevens (Sheffield United) 6

Did little wrong down the left. Offered an outlet going forward on the overlap, which gave Danny McNamara plenty to think about. Used his experience well to keep him under wraps for much of the match.

Jimmy Dunne (QPR) 5

A forgettable return to the club he spent time on loan with early in his career. Like Dickie was left marking thin air for Fleetwood’s first goal and like the rest of the defence has to share some blame for their second as a mis-hit corner was allowed to drift across the box.

Mark McGuinness (Sheffield Weds) 9

If this was, as is expected, to be his last hurrah then he posted a typically stoic defensive performance. If he can perform like this against Premier League opposition then it won't be long before he is playing there on a regular basis.

Nathan Collins (Wolves) 8

Collins was very solid right up until the moment where he misplaced the pass which led to Liverpool’s equaliser. He was pretty good after it too. The Irishman is improving under Lopetegui.

Joe Hodge (Wolves) 7.5

There is so much to like about the diminutive midfielder. He hassles and harries opposing players with an infectious enthusiasm that has endeared him to supporters. Hodge deserves to be called a first team player.

League 1

Paudie O’Connor (Lincoln) 6

Decent at the back, and headed a few balls away, could potentially have got across quicker to block Blackett-Taylor’s shot.

Danny Mandroiu (Lincoln) 7 - Star Man

Lincoln’s brightest spark throughout. Had a few opportunities in the first half that he struck well and got Lincoln back into the game with his goal.

Scottish Premiership 

Liam Scales (Aberdeen) 6 

Not a standout performance from the Celtic loanee, but he went quietly about his business to help Aberdeen secure a morale boosting victory.

Jonny Hayes (Aberdeen) 7

The experienced Irishman has proved to be a useful assest off the bench in the last two games, and was full of running and energy. Got the assist for Duk's second goal with a nicely weighted corner.
Back to Top
MC Hammered View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Oct 2011
Status: Offline
Points: 6833
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote MC Hammered Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 07 Jan 2023 at 10:56pm

Nice one YTM, love this thread 
El Puto Amo
Back to Top
nvidic View Drop Down
Moderator Group
Moderator Group
Avatar

Joined: 03 Aug 2010
Status: Online
Points: 18938
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote nvidic Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 07 Jan 2023 at 11:19pm
Thanks for this, great to have 
Back to Top
korourke View Drop Down
Alan Kernaghan
Alan Kernaghan


Joined: 19 Nov 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 129
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote korourke Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 08 Jan 2023 at 12:00am
YTM, great to see you back in action.
Back to Top
Badgersboys9 View Drop Down
Ray Houghton
Ray Houghton
Avatar

Joined: 12 Oct 2019
Status: Online
Points: 3286
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Badgersboys9 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 08 Jan 2023 at 11:58am
Great stuff YTM, good to have this back!
Back to Top
Eoink21 View Drop Down
Liam Brady
Liam Brady


Joined: 30 Aug 2019
Status: Offline
Points: 1202
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Eoink21 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 08 Jan 2023 at 12:51pm
These ratings are helpful too in that they provide a little more context than the posts highlighting errors. Bazunu, McNally and Collins getting 7 or above when their threads have posters piling into dissect goal concessions they are involved in is interesting. 
Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 11 Jan 2023 at 10:52pm
7/1/23

FA Cup

Jordan Shipley (Shrewsbury) 6

It was always going to be hard for Shipley up against Amad and Patrick Roberts, but he did OK. Roberts did get the better of him on one occasion but Marosi saved well.

Killian Phillips (Shrewsbury) 7

Tested the Sunderland keeper from range with a powerful effort and he got around the pitch really well on his debut. Will hope to build from this. Impressive.

Aiden O’Brien (Shrewsbury) 7

The striker showed some really nice touches in the opening 20 minutes, and if Salop can get him fit and keep him fit, he could be valuable.

Louie Watson (Luton) 8.5 - Star Man

Second start in succession for the youngster and continued his excellent form from New Year's Day with a starring role as the deep-lying midfielder. Always eager to get the ball from his defenders, he was able to turn away from trouble, get his head up and play forwards to find a team-mate or switch the direction of Luton's attack. Forced off by cramp but the home fans liked what they saw. Looks a real find.

8/1/23

FA Cup

Max O'Leary (Bristol City) 6

Question marks about why he put Atkinson under pressure for the opener when he played it to his feet on the edge of the area. Got a few crucial touches to dangerous crosses from wide positions. Did everything expected of him.

Mark Sykes (Bristol City) 7

Tried to get forward at every opportunity and was full of energy and pace down the right side. Eager to take his chance to earn a start in the league.

Ryan Manning (Swansea) 6 

Happy to keep hold of the ball to draw others in and got forward well. Defended typically well at left-back. Tougher second half as he tired and the hosts went direct.

Eiran Cashin (Derby) 8

There were some glorious crossfield passes and in terms of his defending he was reliable and formidable as ever and his partnership with Forsyth is superb.

Conor Hourihane (Derby) 7

Didn't get forward as much as he did against Accrington, but he kept the ball ticking over. His role here was more of a facilitator than a lock picker. Assured.

Jason Knight (Derby) 8

Never stopped harrying Barnsley which would have delighted Warne who wants a side that is hungry in the press. Popped up here, there and everywhere and was rewarded with a goal.

James Collins (Derby) 7

Worked incredibly hard along the front and does the unselfish work so well. Contributed to defending set-pieces too. Rattled home the penalty just before half-time.

Joel Bagan (Cardiff) 7

Started shakily but very much grew into it. Linked up nicely with Philogene and Ojo at times. Some signs of encouragement for him. Sent off for a red card on the line, but had to take one for the team.

Jack Bonham (Stoke) 6

Had to deal with some heavy handling in a crowded box when defending set pieces, being sent to the deck once.

Andrew Omobamidele (Norwich) 7

Adam Idah (Norwich) 5

Scottish Premiership

Aiden McGeady (Hibs) 8

First league start of the season and showed how big a miss he has been during his absence. Set up the first goal, and his pace caused Paul McGinn problems all game. Still has that burst of pace, tracks back well to support his full-back and if he can stay fit, will make a huge difference to this Hibs team.

9/1/23

FA Cup

Ed McGinty (Oxford) 6

Unfortunate to be beaten three times by a ruthless Arsenal and could do little about Mohamed Elneny’s header. He possibly went to ground too early for Eddie Nketiah’s first goal and could’ve made himself bigger for the striker’s second.

11/1/23

EFL Cup

Gavin Bazunu (Southampton) 7

Claimed some early crosses well which will have given him plenty of confidence against his former side. Made himself big when Julian Alvarez raced through at the start of the second half and fired wide. Stayed brave and calm as City's pressure increased, making several key claims and saves.

(Joe Hodge wasn't given a rating as he only came on in the 80th minute)
Back to Top
E2016 View Drop Down
Liam Brady
Liam Brady


Joined: 13 Jan 2016
Location: Cork
Status: Offline
Points: 1700
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote E2016 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 11 Jan 2023 at 10:54pm
Originally posted by You Tell Me You Tell Me wrote:


EFL Cup

Gavin Bazunu (Southampton) 7

Claimed some early crosses well which will have given him plenty of confidence against his former side. Made himself big when Julian Alvarez raced through at the start of the second half and fired wide. Stayed brave and calm as City's pressure increased, making several key claims and saves.

(Joe Hodge wasn't given a rating as he only came on in the 80th minute)


They didn't have a shot on target, so this one is interesting.
Back to Top
You Tell Me View Drop Down
Jack Charlton
Jack Charlton


Joined: 05 Sep 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 6773
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote You Tell Me Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 11 Jan 2023 at 11:02pm
He did make two important saves from awkward crosses though. 
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <1 34567 8>
  Share Topic   

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.00
Copyright ©2001-2018 Web Wiz Ltd.