Caoimhín Kelleher

Neco Williams particularly who is such a talent but very green still and as a habit of looking backwards to pass a bit more then forwards it was a help to him.

I can remember how Randolph became as relevant as he has become. A mistimed overhead kick by Adrian in August 2015 against Leicester City caught Vardy in the face and Adrian was red-carded. Before that, there were wide reports of a deal being set in place between QPR and West Ham that would see Rob Green come back to Upton Park, and that would have sidelined Randolph who had just signed that summer. Instead, Randolph proved himself over three key games at WH, before a tweak sustained by Shay Given in the 2015 game against Germany meant he got his chance in the Irish jersey, and this all established him. But he was relatively old at the time.

Keepers are rarely the ready article when they are young, and it takes time. This is another key factor.

As we've seen with Randolph lately (looks shaky and rusty) not playing regularly tends to effect keepers far more than outfield players, with this in mind could anyone realistically say Kelleher playing 6-8 games a season at Liverpool would be more beneficial right now to his development than playing 30+ games in The Championship?

There are pro's and con's to this of course, but it shouldn't even be up for debate that playing games week in week out far outweighs everything else in regard to a young players development.

I'm not so sure a then 23/24 year old Caoimhin Kelleher with only 20 odd club appearances under his belt (mainly in League Cup games or dead rubbers, you would assume) would fill me with confidence going into a full qualifying campaign.

The reason Molomby is now a firm fixture in the senior set up is on the back of his 40 odd games for Millwall last season, so I'd like to see Kelleher go down the same route.

This must be what the third if not fourth time, I've said I wasn't disagreeing with you in regard to seeing our younger players leaving their clubs to go out on loan? Yet again you cannot seem to grasp this? You're not on the forum a wet week, there aren't too many points that haven't been said numerous times before.....

Your argument was completely fabricated and flawed, all hypothetically speaking hence why I picked you up on it. i.e. speaking about our players in the Bundesliga, again NOT about them going out on loan to Championship clubs. 

Anyhow moving on........

Fair enough just on the Championship where would people rank the Championship as regard strong Leagues in Europe. I’d have it 6th probably behind the Top 5 European Leagues PL La Liga Bundesliga Serie A and Ligue 1 in 6th think that’s a reasonable assumption.

Buffon was outstanding and could have been 7/8.