Arsenal -v- Bayern Munich

Out of interest lads and Im not comparing them btw but I wonder what Brady was like when he was Wilsheres age. Was Brady a slow developer or was he consistantly classy from day one?

He's only young and he's just back from a lengthy injury he looks a real raw talent that'll develop into a very good player.

Wilshere is a better player than cleverly imo 

Vivakenbarlow wrote: Wilshere is clearly talented no ones denying that He gets caught too far forward though like is he a midfielder or is he playing in behind the striker? Doesnt seem to know himself Trying too hard to be roy of the rovers bombing forward at every opportunity looking for the glory Needs more discipline in his game and as i said gives away the ball too cheaply at times

Ken would you welcome him to old Trafford?

Wilshere is clearly talented no ones denying that

Trapped wrote: Roberto Baggio wrote:   You mentioned him going to one of the top clubs - City are just about still in the bracket at the moment provided they can continue their spending patterns. I would see him turning out as similar to Barry and Milner - some way effective in centre midfield but certainly overrated. And from what I've seen of both players this season I'd much prefer Cleverley at United than Wilshere.       that posts just a little bit bitter   Odd that a comment praising Jack Wilshere has turned into comparing him to Tom Cleverly, and two Man City players that play in different positions   Come on lads, you are allowed to admit a player at a different club is good

Cazorla is a class act on his day and a much better player than Wilshere "in the hole". Wilshere gets in Cazorla's way in that position in my opinion - he should play further back.

Wilshere is more talented end of

I don't think Cleverly has Wilsheres range of passing. Cleverly is naturally a more attacking player than the deeper position fergie has him in. Wilshere's plays further up the pitch. Cleverly has got a good shot but he has a serious reluctance to shoot when the shot is on through the middle. He's nearly too unselfish. Wilshere has more ability to influence a game than Cleverly IMO. Id like to see how they get on together in the England team. Id imagine Cleverly would play in behind him as the holding midfielder. I do think Wilshere is a better player though not by much

Vivakenbarlow wrote: bhob wrote: Trapped wrote: Roberto Baggio wrote: Wilshere was head and shoulders above any of his team mates last night. Nearly time he joined one of the big boys, would be some player in a top class side.   City should take him and turn him into another mundane, overrated centre mid like Barry and Milner.   Cleverley is better than Wilshere. I disagree Totally different players Wilshere is wildly over rated- he has good pace over the first 5 yards and can get by a player but his passing is woeful at times- he can tend to be a bit of a headless chicken aswel he was all over the place last night getting caught ahead of the play doing pretty much no defending Cleverley is under rated- his passing and shooting are excellent but again positionally he needs to wise up- goes missing in too many games

Edited by bhob - 20 Feb 2013 at 11:57am