The Celtic Thread

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CwxvPemHYRE&feature=player_embedded

the tuesday bounce game

that lad Tony Watt looks a right good prospect, as does George

Roberto Baggio wrote: that lad Tony Watt looks a right good prospect, as does George Andre Blackman, looked good for a bit then fcked up for their goal.

paul george is a cracking player and one thats on Irelands youth set up as well

hes been brilliant in the next gen series for the U19 team this season. i know lennon has given mcgeugh a run in the team a time but i would also like to see George getting a chance as well

Firstly I think it's deplorable for anyone to come on and call one of our own players a goat. Celtic already have such an animal, goes by the name of Samaras, a lad who wasn't good enough for EPL but is one Celtic's top earners and has been struttin his stuff up there for 4? years.

Secondly, Gibson would piss on the Celtic midfield

Ledley: average championship player, contract ran out at Cardiff went to Celtic cause no EPL team interested
Commons: see above (although Celtic paid 0.5m in last 6 months)
Ki: too light, can't tackle, couldn't deal with pace of premiership
Brown: overrated, headless chicken, 2nd touch a tackle
Kayal: early promise faded, give ball away too often would be decent championship player

Gibson is a good player and I think ppl have got on his back and a campaign has mounted. This lad has come through the academy at one of the biggest clubs in the world, won the prestigious jimmy murphy award, scored in the champions league against bayern and shalke, he's played in a champions league semi final in which he was outstanding, he has a premier league winners medal and played in 2 league final victories.

He has been unlucky with injuries and the form of other players and has no doubt suffered from his falling out with fergie (who is notorious for this). I seem to remember Dunner being written off by a lot of ppl in his early years and I have no doubt that down the line some people will be embarrassed by the comments they have put in here.

Sunderland screwed gibson over at beginning of season but if he does leave in Jan there will be no shortage of takers in the EPL.

I watched Gibson play last wk and McCarthy last night both were almost identical, protected back 4 and played it simple, both played well. Gibson got slated by number of ppl on here and McCarthy got lamented. Gibson even got blamed for missing a tackle on ambrose for the goal even tho it wasn't him that was near him!!

Before anyone starts I don't support united, don't hate Celtic. I just my own opinions and don't follow the sheep or goats!

Bhoydy. could it catch on .....lol

Stillhuntinghenry wrote: Firstly I think it's deplorable for anyone to come on and call one of our own players a goat. Celtic already have such an animal, goes by the name of Samaras, a lad who wasn't good enough for EPL but is one Celtic's top earners and has been struttin his stuff up there for 4? years. Secondly, Gibson would piss on the Celtic midfield Ledley: average championship player, contract ran out at Cardiff went to Celtic cause no EPL team interested Commons: see above (although Celtic paid 0.5m in last 6 months) Ki: too light, can't tackle, couldn't deal with pace of premiership Brown: overrated, headless chicken, 2nd touch a tackle Kayal: early promise faded, give ball away too often would be decent championship player Gibson is a good player and I think ppl have got on his back and a campaign has mounted. This lad has come through the academy at one of the biggest clubs in the world, won the prestigious jimmy murphy award, scored in the champions league against bayern and shalke, he's played in a champions league semi final in which he was outstanding, he has a premier league winners medal and played in 2 league final victories. He has been unlucky with injuries and the form of other players and has no doubt suffered from his falling out with fergie (who is notorious for this). I seem to remember Dunner being written off by a lot of ppl in his early years and I have no doubt that down the line some people will be embarrassed by the comments they have put in here. Sunderland screwed gibson over at beginning of season but if he does leave in Jan there will be no shortage of takers in the EPL. I watched Gibson play last wk and McCarthy last night both were almost identical, protected back 4 and played it simple, both played well. Gibson got slated by number of ppl on here and McCarthy got lamented. Gibson even got blamed for missing a tackle on ambrose for the goal even tho it wasn't him that was near him!! Before anyone starts I don't support united, don't hate Celtic. I just my own opinions and don't follow the sheep or goats!

Did unbelievable with Rangers.
sh*te against us but some goal scoring record he had

Sunderland reneged on an initial salary offer to Gibson, Gibson wanted to hold them to that figure, simple as.

U have grand ideas of the Celtic midfield whilst they might cut it in Scotland that midfield would be Relegation material in the EPL. Funny that all these EPL teams want these players yet none of them have played in EPL. Even more surprising given that the likes of Stoke can far outbid Celtic when it comes to wages with the television money inbalance north and south of border. The facts are there these guys didn't attract an EPL club even tho they have all been available at one time or another.

Robson, McManus, McDonald, Maloney, Caldwell have hardly set England alight in last few years. Fact again

Whens the last time an EPL left their club to sign for celtic or rangers??

If you think gibson ain't a good player then critically analyse why this is the case but don't say he wouldnt make it in a bunch of nobodys in a third rate team in a third rate league.

As a fan I'm disappointed that Gibson hasn't hit the heights that we all hoped but it has not been down to lack of ability and that's why I'm confident he'll come good with an injury free run of games
Ilovetrap - ur like a broken record slating Gibson, mcshane and keogh. Can't take u serious tho since u said ur friend text u from Elland rd to say Keogh was hauled off cause he was terrible - even tho Leeds were playing at the other end of the country at vicarage road